Can My Faith Just Be Private, Between Me and God?
No building. No membership. No one checking on you. Just you and God, quietly, on your own terms. It sounds cleaner. It isn't what Scripture describes.
I understand the appeal. Church can be messy — people disappoint you, institutions get political, services can feel more like performance than encounter. So the instinct makes sense: keep the relationship, lose the room full of other people. But I want to gently push back on the premise, because the New Testament simply does not describe faith as something designed to survive alone.
The Language Itself Won't Let You Go Solo
Open almost any New Testament letter and you run into it constantly: love one another. Encourage one another. Forgive one another. Carry one another's burdens (Galatians 6:2). Confess your faults to one another, and pray for one another (James 5:16). You cannot obey a single one of those verses alone in a room with your phone and a devotional. They require another person. Not a metaphorical one — an actual, present, sometimes-inconvenient human being.
That's not incidental to the gospel. It's structural to it.
What You Lose Without It
Paul told the elders at Ephesus, "Take heed therefore unto yourselves, and to all the flock" (Acts 20:28). Notice the order — watch yourself, and watch the flock. A private faith only ever manages the first half. And here's the danger in that: a tired, drifting believer is usually the last person to notice they're drifting. "Most trouble does not announce itself." It shows up quietly, in the small compromises nobody's around to name — until someone who actually knows you does.
That's what community is for. Not to control you. To see what you can't see about yourself.
The Tension Is Real, But It Doesn't Cancel the Call
I won't pretend there's no tension here. A few verses after "carry one another's burdens," Paul also says each person will "bear his own load" (Galatians 6:5). Both are true. There are things — your own repentance, your own decisions before God — that no one else can carry for you. But there are also weights that were never meant to be carried alone, and the wisdom is in telling the difference, not in picking one verse and ignoring the other.
The Church, at its healthiest, isn't a building you attend. It's the family Christ actually built — bought by His own blood, meant to function as a body, not a scattered collection of individuals who happen to believe the same thing. You were never meant to figure out your faith entirely by yourself. You were built into something.
Go Deeper: The Church: As a Governing Body
Pastor Timilehin Idowu's full-length book on what the Church actually is — not a building or an institution, but a family bought by blood. Free. No cost. No sign-up.
Read It Free →